in

Best Ocracoke Island Restaurants: Your Dining Guide

ocracoke island restaurants

Love this kind of thing? Share it or pin it for your next scroll sesh!

Pinterest
Facebook
Email

Looking for the best options for Ocracoke Island restaurants? We have the top locales to plan each meal while you are on Ocracoke Island in the Outer Banks.

Ocracoke Island

While growing up in North Carolina, Ocracoke Island was the dreamiest little island. That hasn’t changed. However, the memories of it being so far away have changed. If you live in North Carolina, you may already think it is a day trip just to get there.

Here’s the thing: the ferry ride over is where your getaway begins. Take advantage of the boat ride over, even though it is a 2-3 hour ferry ride (depending on which ferry you take). It is worth it!

beaches of ocracoke island

Now that you have planned your trip, or maybe you are on the way there now, the next big decision is deciding where to dine for each meal. 

Sure, Ocracoke Island is small, but it has much to offer regarding nosh and cuisine. 

Dining at Ocracoke Island Restaurants: Your Guide

Whether camping, staying at an Airbnb, or lodging at the Pony Island Inn, we’ve covered your dining guide while you are on Ocracoke Island. 

When I (shannon) was a youngster, my mom took me and my brother on what was supposed to be a day trip to Ocracoke Island from Cedar Island. Little did she know that we took the last ferry over and could not get a way back. 

I remember it being the most fun adventure, even though we could hardly afford the ferry ride then. Mom was able to secure the last motel room on the island. We ate out for every meal but did it on a budget. 

Fast-forward to these days, and Gerry and I have tried every dining spot on the island. Even when camping, we still love to visit the local spots and show our support. 

ocracoke island restaurants
We’ve often walked to Ocracoke Coffee Company and brought the coffee back to our campsite to enjoy!

Breakfast Spots

They say breakfast is the most important meal of the day! Let’s start with breaking the fast on Ocracoke.

Ocracoke Coffee Company

We love Ocracoke Coffee Company, not just for its coffee but also for its location. Head inside to grab your coffee or latte of choice. Pick a pastry or bagel, then head outside to sit at a patio table or our fave, an Adirondack chair. It’s a fabulous way to start the perfect Ocracoke day!

Pony Island Restaurant

A breakfast place that only serves breakfast is doing it right! They are open daily (except Tuesdays) from 7am – 11:30am. Try an omlette or french toast! Do not forget to order a side of grits. You will thank us later!

Lunch Faves

Lunchtime is a busy time on the island. People come off of boats to grab a bite and a beer. Others have been out enjoying their golf cart rides around Ocracoke. Keep in mind that you’re on island time. Chill and enjoy lunch at one of the Ocracoke Island restaurants.

ocracoke island restaurants

Plum Pointe Kitchen

We ended up at Plum Pointe since they were the only people in Google who came up as having vegetarian options for lunch. Others do, but they advertised that they do, so it was our first choice!

You can grab some cheese curds, nachos, the typical bar food, or you can go all out for their famous crab-stuffed jumbo pretzel!

Ocracoke Oyster Company

Oysters are what most people head here for! We love their French bread pizza and their veggie burger, and Gerry loves their mahi tacos!

It has a great vibe, whether outdoor seating or indoors. They also have cool merch available so grab a hat or t-shirt so you can remember your awesome Ocracoke Island trip!

Dinner Plans Secured!

Local seafood is a big hit for visitors to Ocracoke. Since it is a big demand, you may want to call and see if dinner reservations need to be made. Otherwise, if the restaurants are on a wait, enjoy the vibe. Ask if you can grab a cocktail and chill while you wait. 

ocracoke island restaurants

Howard’s Pub

If you go to Ocracoke and don’t eat at Howards’ Pub, did you really even go to Ocracoke? Now, be aware that Howard’s does not accept reservations, so go earlier than you plan to eat and drool while you wait. 

They have indoor and outdoor seating, a super laid-back vibe, and a raw bar for you looking for some fresh seafood! 

Non-seafood eaters? No prob! Grab their Beyond Burger and some onion rings and you will be good to go!

Flying Melon 

Flying Melon Cafe is for those who want a slightly more upscale dinner experience. That said, don’t stress about what you wear if you only bring beachy, chill clothes. 

Their menu will pacify anyone looking for some Ocracoke oysters, locally caught seafood, and creole dishes. 

Gerry Arner sitting on wall on the island.
Ocracoke is a very cool island with fabulous dining locales!

Fellow vegetarians, just ask what they offer in lieu of meat. The last time we were there, they made an eggplant dish as part of their dinner specials. They are super accommodating!

Happy Hour

We’d be remiss in this Ocracoke Island Restaurants guide by not telling you where to go for cocktails and beer for happy hour or anytime. 

SmacNally’s Waterfront Bar

We spent a very long happy hour here the last time we were on the island. We had a very long happy hour because we arrived just after lunch, then enjoyed happy hour. The vibe is super cool! Watch the water and boats, and drink a few rounds of beer in a SmacNally cup!

Bonus: the cup is a cool souvenir that doubles as functional when you get home. That’s the kind of take-home souvenir we love!

Zillie’s Island Pantry

We have Zillie’s on the happy hour recommendations because you can either grab some beer or wine and enjoy it on their porch, or you can grab it to go and enjoy watching the sunset. 

Gerry loves making his own 6-pack of different beers, and I love grabbing a wine that will pair well with whatever food or nosh we will enjoy at sunset. 

Outer Banks sunset
Grabbing happy hour to go to watch the sunset is a must-do while on the island!

Note- we love grabbing to-go beer or wine from Zillie’s, but always check to see if anything changes with the local laws on having alcohol on the beach. We have always been able to drink responsibly on the beach. Just don’t be a jerk and leave your trash. You’ll ruin it for all of us, and we will be super pissed.

Island Desserts

If you didn’t grab something sweet at dinner, no worries! Let’s talk about our favorite meal of the day: dessert!

Fig Tree Bakery + Sweet Tooth

We ventured in one evening for something sweet, and oh em gee! This place is amazing!

Grab some ice cream and a smidge of fudge. Put it in the same container and prepare for your world to be rocked most sweetly!

If you want to get even more jacked up, do it in the morning! Sort of kidding, but seriously. They are open from 8am to 8pm so you can grab coffee and sweets and be on for the day!

ocracoke island restaurants

The Slushy Stand

Don’t be caught off guard about The Slushy Stand. They are more than just slushies. However, a cold, fresh fruit slushy on a hot evening hits the spot!

We love their milkshakes, but our absolute fave is a couple of scoops of chocolate ice cream in a homemade waffle cone. Can you see the drool on this screen as we type this?

Ocracoke Island Restaurants Do Not Disappoint

Whether you try one of our recommendations for a meal or venture to one not on the list, you will be hard-pressed to find a negative experience. Remember, in-season is the island’s bread and butter, so always be patient. 

While we hope you enjoy this Ocracoke Island Restaurants guide, remember to respect hospitality workers. We hear there is a special place in hell for people who are not kind and patient to restaurant workers. Just saying!

Don’t Miss These Outer Banks Experiences!

https://www.viator.com/orion/partner/widget.js

FAQs | Frequently Asked Questions

How do I get to Ocracoke Island?

Most people get to Ocracoke by ferry from Hatteras, Swan Quarter, or Cedar Island. If you have your own boat or plane, you can go that route, too.

When is the best time to go to Ocracoke Island?

Summer is the busiest, but we enjoy going in the fall. Note that some businesses are closed when they are “out of season,” so always check before betting on heading to your fave restaurant or bar if you go in the off-season.

What are the top things to do in Ocracoke?

The top highlights are the Ocracoke Lighthouse, the British Cemetery, and the Ocracoke Ponies.

Pinterest
Facebook
LinkedIn
Reddit
Threads
Picture of Shannon + Gerry Arner | Arner Adventures

Shannon + Gerry Arner | Arner Adventures

Hi, we’re Shannon and Gerry Arner, the couple behind Arner Adventures. After burnout pushed us to rethink how we were living, we sold our business, our home, and most of our belongings to make more room for intentional travel, simple living, and everyday adventures. Since 2017, we’ve written and published more than 1,000 articles covering travel, minimalism, wellness, sustainability, and building an online business. Everything we write comes from our firsthand experiences and the lessons we’ve learned along the way. Our goal is to share honest, practical information that helps others live with less clutter and more intention.

LOOKING FOR SOMETHING?

Scroll to Top